Skip to content
Download Consolidated Credit's Free Debt Relief Guide

Are prepaid cards a good idea?

Reviewed by:
Executive Director

prepaid cards

The popularity of prepaid debit and credit cards is growing fast. On the surface, they seem like a good idea, right? You’re not using credit to purchase things so you’re not spending beyond your means. 

While prepaid cards offer a good alternative to using credit, there are a number of things to consider.

“When it comes to trying to stick to a budget, living a cash-only lifestyle is best. However, there are circumstances where using a credit card (or a debit card) is more convenient or in some cases required. In this way, prepaid cards can be a great alternative to traditional credit,” says Jeff Schwartz, executive director, Consolidated Credit Canada.

“There are still a number of points to consider, like some of the fine print and if the use of these cards are in support of your longer term goals,” says Schwartz.

Prepaid Cards Pros & Cons

Pro: Budgeting tool

One definite plus is that using a prepaid card can really help you budget your money because the amount is finite. Much like using cash only, there is no risk of spending beyond your means. When it is gone, it’s gone. They help with budgeting too because they require planning- both in terms of use and tracking.

Pro: Convenience

Doing online shopping and booking flights; hotels and cars can be tough without using a credit card. But what if you really want to avoid credit use? A prepaid card will help you get around that, so that is a convenient benefit.  However, you will want to make sure that there is enough funds on the card for the purchase or that the retailer will allow their use.

Pro: Great to help family

Let’s say you have a child away at school who needs money or a senior parent who could potentially be vulnerable to scams. Supplying them with a prepaid card gives them the autonomy to spend without a lot of the potential danger of letting them have a traditional card.

Pro: Safety

There is a lot of safety around prepaid cards. For instance, when you travel you won’t worry about a financial breach. Your personal credit card information is safe. A prepaid card is a good option to combat online identity theft. However, you don’t have liability protection in the same way that you do for a traditional credit card.

Con: Replacement

If your prepaid card is stolen, it’s gone. There is no way to recover funds or replace the stolen card.

Con: Not helpful for your credit history

While prepaid cards are great in the sense that they are available to people with no credit history or a poor credit history, they ultimately aren’t doing anything to help you change that; they don’t establish credit history. The only way that you can clean up your credit (or prove yourself in the first place) is to consistently use and make your payments each and every month.

If your goal is to establish credit, your goal may be better served by taking out a credit card. Keep a small balance card, make small purchases you will be able to pay off in full every month. If you are a high-risk borrower, your lender may even agree to give you a credit card if you secure it with cash. That way you are establishing credit, but also have cash should you need to shut down the card and pay it off.

Con: Be aware of the fees

One way to clean up your credit is to pay down your debt and start fresh. We can help you formulate a plan. Call us at (855) 895-2684 or visit our online debt analysis.

Another drawback is that a number of cards have pretty substantial fees, like activation and per-use fees, which can really eat away at your balance. In the end, you need to make very sure that you’ve read all the fine print in detail before you purchase.

What is your total credit card debt amount?

Provide a few details about yourself.

##first_name##, here are your next steps...

Get a clear picture of your spending vs. your income. Begin your online budget and financial analysis now by clicking the button above.

Our experts are here to help you understand your options and reach your goals. After you complete the easy-to-use online budget, one of our trained counsellors will reach out to you and provide recommendations.

Everything shared is 100% confidential and secure.

I understand and agree that by choosing “Start your online budget now”, I am voluntarily providing certain personal financial information in order to educate myself as to my current financial position. I understand that this budget tool is educational in nature, and that none of the information received in the form of a budget constitutes financial advice, nor does it constitute a counselling session. I understand and agree that the budget depends on the information I input into the fields, and that Company does not represent or guarantee the accuracy of the budget. I understand that this tool may collect information and should I choose not to provide such information, I am not to proceed further. If I choose to abandon the tool midway through the process, I understand that the information will not be maintained and I would be required to start providing the information from the beginning. Company disclaims all warranties associated with the budget tool herein. I understand and agree that Company may use the contact information provided herein to contact me through various means of communications, including automated messages, and that I expressly consent to receive these messages.

Consolidated Credit Counseling Services of Canada Inc BBB accredited business profile